CRLs vs. Alternatives: OCSP and Certificate Transparency Logs

Follow SSLREPO latest news

CRLs vs. Alternatives: OCSP and Certificate Transparency Logs

Well, buckle up, because we’re about to delve into the wild world of SSL certificates and the critical “blacklists” that keep the internet from turning into a digital garbage dump! We’re talking about Certificate Revocation Lists (CRLs) , and trust me, you want to know about them.

Think of it this way:  your SSL certificate is your website’s VIP pass into the “Secure Internet Club.” It proves that your website is legitimate and that your data is encrypted. But what happens if that VIP pass is stolen, damaged, or expires prematurely? That’s where CRLs come in like digital superheroes!

What is a Certificate Revocation List (CRL)? It’s a blacklist of SSL certificates!

Imagine a bouncer at the door of the secure internet club. He has a list – the CRL. This list is maintained by the issuing authority (CA) (the one who issued the VIP pass in the first place) and contains the serial numbers of all the certificates that have been revoked. Revoked means “revoked”, “canceled”, “no longer valid”.

Oh dear, let me count the ways…

 Compromised Keys:  Someone got their hands on your private keys. This is like losing your house key – time to lock it up (and revoke the certificate)!
 Compromised CA:  The CA itself got hacked! This is a big deal, like when someone’s bodyguard got bribed. Those VIP passes they issued are now suspect.
  Certificate Issue Error:  Oops! The CA made a mistake and issued a certificate to the wrong site. It happens. Time to fix it with a revocation.
  Certificate Change:  Did you sell your site? The new owners need their own VIP passes.
  Ceased Operations: Site shut down? Time to revoke that certificate so no one tries to impersonate a dead site.
Compromised Certificate:  The site owner did something bad, and their certificate can no longer be trusted.

How do CRL statements work?

This works really well. When your browser visits a website, it checks the website’s SSL certificate. Part of the check involves looking up a “CRL De Facto Distribution Point” (CDP) – basically, the address where the CRL is located.

1. Browser goes to Bouncer:  Your browser says, “Hey, is this certificate on a blacklist?”
2. Bouncer checks list: The browser downloads the CRL and scans it to find the certificate’s serial number.
3. Good or bad?
  Not on the list?  You’re in! Secure connection established.
  On the list?  Red alert! The browser issues a warning and blocks you from connecting to a potentially dangerous site.

The problem with CRLs: They can be a little… slow.

All of a sudden there is a long list of malicious certificates. It takes time to download and check it, right? That’s the downside of CRLs. They can be massive and large, and the checking process is slow. Also, they are only updated periodically, so for some time, a revoked certificate may still be overlooked.

Enter the alternative: OCSP and certificate (CT) logging!

Think of these as upgrades to your security system.

  OCSP (Online Certificate Status Protocol): Instead of downloading the whole bad list, the browser can just ask the CA directly: “Hey, is this certificate valid?” It’s like calling a bouncer, but waiting in line. OCSP
  Stapling: Even better! The website does the checking and “staples” the “everything is OK” signal to the certificate. Faster, more.

Certificate (CT) logs: These logs are like a public, permanent record of every certificate issued. Think of it as a large, searchable database of VIP-pass certificates. It helps find bad or mis-issued certificates, but doesn’t directly handle revoking certificates.

So, what are its best features?

They each have their advantages! CRLs are good for bulk updates, OCSP is good for real-time checks, and CT logs provide transparency. Smart websites and CAs often use a combination of these methods for maximum security. It’s like having multiple bodyguards and security cameras.

Bottom line: keep your website secure!

CRLs, OCSPs, and CT logs are all part of a complex and critical system that keeps the Internet safe. They are the unsung heroes that protect us from the digital bad guys.

If you want to make sure your website has a valid, trusted SSL certificate, head over to SSL ROPE. They have a large collection of certificates from well-known CAs , and they will help you find the best one for your needs. Don’t let your website get blacklisted!

Scroll to Top